Invasion History

First Non-native North American Tidal Record: 2018
First Non-native West Coast Tidal Record:
First Non-native East/Gulf Coast Tidal Record: 2018

General Invasion History:

The encrusting bryozoan Cribrilina mutabilis was described from the Akkeshi-ko estuary, northern Japan in 2014, but was found at about the same time off Kristineberg on the west coast of Sweden (Ostrovsky, cited by Ito et al. 2015), and off Norway (Trott and Enterline 2019). It is probably native to the Northwest Pacific, including Japan and possibly Russia (Ito et al. 2015). In the Akkeshi-ko estuary, C. mutabilis was exclusively associated with Eelgrass (Zostera marina) (Ito et al. 2015), but in Sweden was associated with brown algae (Fucus spp. (Rockweed), Laminaria sp. (Kelp) (Ostrovsky, cited by Ito et al. 2015). This bryozoan was once found on a hard substrate, as a dead colony on a plastic bin associated with tsunami debris (McCuller et al. 2018). A possibly conspecific form, Klugerella aragoi ex grege has been reported from the Russian coasts of the Seas of Japan and Okhotsk (Kubanin, 1998, cited by Ito et al. 2015). The term ‘ex grege’ means ‘one of the group’, meaning that it is related to K. aragoi, known from Florida and Egypt (Bock 2019). Unlike C. mutabilis in Japan, K. aragoi ex grege in Pacific Russia does not have multiple types of zooids, and settles on hard substrates (shells, wharves, fouling plates, boats) as well as Eelgrass and algae (Kubanin, 1998, cited by Ito et al. 2015). These differences could be related to local conditions or indicate genetic divergence. In 2018, C. mutabilis was found growing on Eelgrass in Casco Bay, Maine its first occurrence in the Northwest Atlantic (Trott and Enterline 2019).

North American Invasion History:

Invasion History on the East Coast:

On September 12, 2018, large numbers of colonies of C. mutabilis were found on Eelgrass growing around three islands - Clapboard, Mackworth, and Hog Islands in Casco Bay, Maine. Most colonies were on the brown, decaying tips of the leaves. All three zooid types were found, but the I (intermediate) form was most common. Ancestrulae and young colonies were found on Eelgrass. No colonies were found on shell, cobble, or bedrock. At one location, colonies were also found on decaying, drifting kelp. Colonies of C. mutabilis were found near Portland Harbor, a major seaport, receiving ships from Europe. However, more surveys are needed to determine whether other populations are found on the East Coast of North America (Trott and Enterline 2019).


Description

The encrusting bryozoan Cribrilina mutabilis forms small (5-7mm), flat, roughly circular, whitish to tan colonies with orange embryos. This species is polymorphic with three types of zooids, each varying in abundance seasonally (Ito et al. 2015; Trott and Enterline 2019). These types are so distinct morphologically, they might be misidentified as different species. However, DNA sequencing of the mitochondrial COI gene shows they are from the same species (Ito et al. 2015). In general, the zooids are oval, separated by a sharp groove, have 2 to 3 distal spines, and lack avicularia. The gymnocyst is smooth proximally and barely distinguishable laterally. The highly convex spinocyst has large, non-articulated costae (ribs), their width and degree of fusion distinguishing the zooid types. An opesia occupies the entire frontal area of a zooid and is bounded by a raised mural lip. Reproductive zooids have a vestigial ooecium (ovicell) at their distal end and contain a single embryo (Ito et al. 2015; Trott and Enterline 2019).

The ancestrula (initial zooid of a colony) can be any of the three types: R (rib), I (intermediate), and S (shield). The ancestrula is usually surrounded by seven periancestrular zooids, one distal and two each in distolateral, proximolateral, and proximal positions. Initially, budding is in the distal direction and results in a unidirectional colony. Growth in proximal and proximolateral directions follow producing a more circular colony (Ito et al. 2015; Trott and Enterline 2019).

The three zooid types differ most notably in the number and development of the costal ribs. R-type zooids have the likeness of a human ribcage formed by 8-12 strongly developed widely spaced ribs, fused along the midline that has no intercostal pores. I-type zooids are similar in shape to R-type ones but have 8-13 ribs as wide as the width of the intercostal openings. The ribs are fused along the midline creating a narrow elliptical shield with scattered pores. S-type zooids have 12-15 ribs fused along their lateral margins creating a broad shield with many small intercostal pores arranged in radial series. At least two zooid types can co-occur in a colony, however no colonies containing a mix of R- and S-types have been observed (Ito et al. 2015; Trott and Enterline 2019).

Colonies of Cribrilina mutabilis in the Akkeshi-Ko estuary grew exclusively on Eelgrass (Zostera marina) (Ito et al. 2015). In Casco Bay, Maine, most specimens were found on live Eelgrass blades or their decaying tips, but some were found on young Knotted Wrack (Ascophyllum nodosum) and decaying laminarian kelp (Trott and Enterline 2019). Off Kristinebegg, Sweden, C. mutabilis grew on Zostera sp., Laminaria spp., and Fucus spp. (Ostrovsky, cited Ito et al. 2015). One dead colony of this bryozoan was found on a mussel shell attached to tsunami debris washed onto the US North Pacific coast (McCuller and Carlton 2018). Reports from Pacific Russia of bryozoans identified as Klugerella sp. aff. aragoi, possibly C. mutabilis instead, describe settlement on shells, cobbles, pilings, and boats (Kubanin 1997 cited in Ito et al. 2015).

Colonies on Eelgrass in Japan, Russia, Sweden, Norway, and Maine show broadly similar patterns of seasonally changing morphology, but zooid frequencies vary on non-Eelgrass substrates. Zooids encircling thin stalks of the brown alga Cystoseira tamariscifolia, in Sweden, become greatly elongated (Dick et al. 2020).


Taxonomy

Taxonomic Tree

Kingdom:   Animalia
Phylum:   Bryozoa
Class:   Gymnolaemata
Order:   Cheilostomata
Family:   Cribrilinidae
Genus:   Cribrilina
Species:   mutabilis

Synonyms

Membraniporella aragoni (None, None)

Potentially Misidentified Species

Cribrilina annulata
Native, amphi-Atlantic (Trott and Enterline 2019)

Cribrilina cryptooecium
Native, amphi-Atlantic (Trott and Enterline 2019)

Cribrilina macropunctata
Native, west Atlantic (Trott and Enterline 2019)

Ecology

General:

The encrusting bryozoan Cribrilina mutabilis forms small colonies on Eelgrass (Zostera marinaCribrilina annulata, lecithotrophic larvae are brooded and released, settling after a short planktonic period. Chances of settling on favorable substrates are increased by behavioral responses to metabolites liberated from algae and other fouling organisms, in addition to the influence of physical factors on settlement (Yagunova and Ostrovsky 2010). The settled larva becomes an ancestrula. In C. mutabilis, the ancestrula can be any of the three zooid types. Zooids do not transform from one kind to another but can bud the same or an alternative type. The overwintering type is not known, but the late summer appearance of nonreproductive S-type zooids suggests this one may be, at least in Japan. Since S-type zooids do not reproduce sexually, Ito et al. (2015) hypothesize that resources otherwise invested into reproduction might instead be used in the development of the stronger, more complete, S-type costal shield that may offer better protection from stormy winter conditions.

Cribrilina mutabilis is known only from cold-temperate climates in the northern hemisphere, specifically northern Japan, Norway, the west coast of Sweden, and Casco Bay, Maine. Its type locality, the Akkeshi-ko estuary, has salinities ranging from 6 to 27 PSU, but C. mutabilis was found in a narrower range of 24.5 to 27.6 PSU. Among reported locations, its preferred habitats seem to be in the poly- and euhaline range (21-35 PSU) (Ito et al. 2015; Trott and Enterline 2019). In the Akkeshi-ko estuary, colonies of C. mutabilis are known to occur only on Eelgrass (Zostera marina). In Sweden and Casco Bay, they occur mainly on Eelgrass and brown algae (Saccharna latissima; Cytoseira tamariscifolia), Fucus spp., Ascophyllum nodosum) (Ito et al. 2015; Trott and Enterline 2019). This bryozoan is often found on dying tips of living Eelgrass blades and sometimes on decaying drift algae, but this may be because the colonies outlive the plants (Trott and Enterline 2019). In a marina in Scotland, C.mutabilis was found on fouling plates suspended from pontoons. One colony ws found on unidentified algae growing on a pontoon (Dick et al. 2020). As bryozoans, colonies of C. mutabilis are suspension feeders, feeding on phytoplankton and detritus.

Food:

Phytoplankton, detritus

Trophic Status:

Suspension Feeder

SusFed

Habitats

General HabitatGrass BedNone
General HabitatRockyNone
General HabitatOyster ReefNone


Tolerances and Life History Parameters

Minimum Temperature (ºC)4Field, Bergen, Norway (Dick et al. 2020)
Maximum Temperature (ºC)18Field, Casco Bay, Maine (Dick et al. 2020)
Minimum Salinity (‰)21Field, Kristineberg Marine Station, Sweden (Trott and Enterline 2018)
Maximum Salinity (‰)35Field, Casco Bay. ME (Trott and Enterline 2019).
Minimum Length (mm)5Typical colony size (Ito et al. 2015)
Maximum Length (mm)7Typical colony size (Ito et al. 2015)
Broad Temperature RangeNoneCold-Temperate
Broad Salinity RangeNonePolyhaline-Euhaline

General Impacts

Ecological and economic impacts of the encrusting bryozoan, Cribrilina mutabilis, are unknown. However, it has been found growing on Eelgrass (Zostera marina). An abundant fouling organism could adversely affect the growth and survival of Eelgrass, which an important component of marine habitats, and an indicator of water and habitat quality. The occurrence of this bryozoan on Eelgrass should be monitored.

Regional Distribution Map

Bioregion Region Name Year Invasion Status Population Status
NWP-4b None 2014 Native Estab
B-I None 2011 Def Estab
NA-ET2 Bay of Fundy to Cape Cod 2018 Def Estab
N100 Casco Bay 2018 Def Estab
NWP-5 None 1984 Native Estab
NWP-4a None 0 Native Estab
AR-V None 2008 Def Estab
NEA-II None 2013 Def Estab

Occurrence Map

OCC_ID Author Year Date Locality Status Latitude Longitude

References

2003-2013 Recent and Fossil Bryozoa. http://www.bryozoa.net/index.html

Dick, Matthew H.; Waeschenbach, Andrea; Trott, Thomas J.; Onishi, Takumi; Beveridge, Chris ; Bishop, John D. D.; Ito, Minako; Ostrovsky, Andrew N. (2020) Global distribution and variation of the Invasive cheilostome bryozoan Cribrilina mutabilis, Zoological Science 37: 485-497

Gueron, Rodrigo; Almeida, Alexandre Oliveira; Aguilar, Robert; Ogburn, Matthew B.; Prakash, Sanjeevi ; Baeza, J. Antonio (2022) Delimiting species within the Lysmata vittata (Stimpson, 1860) (Decapoda: Lysmatidae) species complex in a world full of invaders, Zootaxa 5150(2): 189–216

Ito, K.; Goshima, S.; Nakao, S. (1996) Growth and reproduction of the generalist opisthobranch Haloa japonica: effect of algal seasonality on growth rate, Marine Biology 126: 395-401

Trott, Thomas J.; Enterline, Claire (2019) First record of the encrusting bryozoan Cribrilina ( Juxtacribrilina ) mutabilis (Ito, Onishi and Dick, 2015) in the Northwest Atlantic Ocean, BioInvasions Records 8: 598-607

Yagunova, Ekaterina B.; Ostrovsky, Andrew N. (2010) The influence of substrate type on sexual reproduction of the bryozoan Cribrilina annulata (Gymnolaemata, Cheilostomata): A case study from Arctic seas, Marine Biology Research 6: 263-270